Fee comparison · New Zealand
Etsy vs Shopify fees New Zealand
Short answer: at a NZ$40 item with NZ$8 postage, Etsy costs about NZ$5.06 per order in New Zealand, while a Shopify store costs about NZ$1.57 per order plus $65 NZD/month. Above 19 orders a month, the Shopify store is cheaper on fees alone. This page compares Etsy selling fees in New Zealand with Shopify transaction fees, using 2026 rates checked from the official fee pages.
Key facts
- Etsy transaction fee: 6.5% of the item price plus shipping charged.
- Etsy payment processing (New Zealand, domestic orders): 3% + NZ$0.30 per order.
- Etsy regulatory operating fee (New Zealand): none — New Zealand is not on Etsy’s regulatory operating fee list.
- Shopify Basic plan (New Zealand): $65 NZD/month on monthly billing, billed in NZD.
- Shopify online card rate (New Zealand): 2.65% + NZ$0.30 per order.
All figures from Sharpfee’s verified fee set, checked against the official fee pages linked in the footer.
Side by side — New Zealand, NZ$48 order total
| Platform | Fee per order | Fees at 50 orders/month |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy | NZ$5.06 | NZ$253.00 |
| Shopify (Basic, monthly) | NZ$1.57 + $65 NZD/mo | NZ$143.60 |
Monthly Shopify figure = 50 × NZ$1.57 + $65 NZD subscription: NZ$78.60 + $65 = NZ$143.60. No conversion needed — the subscription is billed in NZD.
How the Etsy figure is built
Transaction fee 6.5% of NZ$48 = NZ$3.12, listing fee $0.20, payment processing 3% of NZ$48 + NZ$0.30 = NZ$1.74. Total NZ$5.06 per order. Note: the Etsy listing fee in New Zealand is $0.20 per listing, billed in USD and shown at face value, as in the calculator. New Zealand is not on Etsy’s regulatory operating fee list, so no regulatory fee applies. The 4% + NZ$0.30 rate applies to international orders only and is not modelled here.
How the Shopify figure is built
Online card rate 2.65% of NZ$48 + 30¢ = NZ$1.57 per order, plus the Basic plan at $65 NZD/month on monthly billing. Shopify lists the New Zealand plan in NZD (yearly billing is $59 NZD/month and is not used here). At 50 orders that is NZ$78.60 in card fees plus the subscription, or NZ$143.60 a month. No currency conversion is needed for the subscription.
When each wins
Below 19 orders a month, Etsy is cheaper on fees alone because there is no subscription to spread. Above 19 orders, the Shopify store wins on fees alone — but Etsy brings its own buyers, while a Shopify store needs its own marketing. Run your own prices in the Breakeven Planner.
Fee-only comparison: it does not include discovery, traffic, refunds, apps, fulfilment, packaging, or taxes. Subscription is spread over the month’s orders in the monthly figure. Confirm with your seller dashboard before pricing decisions.
The 19-order crossover needs no currency conversion — the subscription is billed in NZD and every other figure is already in NZD. The Etsy listing fee is billed in USD ($0.20) and shown at face value, as before.
Sources (official pages): Etsy fees, Etsy Payments, Etsy regulatory operating fee, Shopify New Zealand pricing, Reserve Bank of New Zealand exchange rates. Figures checked 12 Nov 2026.
Which is cheaper?
This Etsy vs Shopify fees New Zealand 2026 comparison comes down to order volume, not the per-order fee alone. At the NZ$40 item (NZ$48 order total), Etsy takes NZ$5.06 per order and Shopify takes NZ$1.57 per order plus $65 NZD a month.
At 10 orders a month: Etsy costs NZ$50.60 (10 × NZ$5.06); Shopify costs NZ$80.72 (10 × NZ$1.57 + $65 NZD). Etsy is cheaper.
At 19 orders a month: Etsy costs NZ$96.14; Shopify costs NZ$94.87. Shopify is cheaper — this is the crossover point.
At 50 orders a month: Etsy costs NZ$253.00; Shopify costs NZ$143.60. Shopify is clearly cheaper on fees alone.
Looked at the other way — Shopify vs Etsy fees New Zealand — the answer is the same: Shopify wins only once your volume covers the $65 NZD monthly subscription. Below that, Etsy’s per-order-only fees are cheaper, and Etsy brings its own buyers. Run your own prices in the Breakeven Planner — it works as an Etsy fees New Zealand calculator, with the New Zealand rates built in.
Frequently asked questions
Is Shopify always cheaper than Etsy in New Zealand?
No. Only above the fee-only crossover — 19 orders a month at a NZ$48 order total. No currency conversion is needed — the Shopify subscription is billed in NZD. At lower volumes Etsy can be cheaper on fees alone, and it brings marketplace traffic a new store does not have.
Does Etsy charge a monthly subscription?
No. Etsy charges per-order fees only: transaction, listing, and payment processing.
What is not included here?
Discovery and traffic, refunds, apps, fulfilment, packaging, and taxes. This is a fee-only comparison, not a profit forecast.
Which is cheaper in New Zealand, Etsy or Shopify?
It depends on volume. At a NZ$48 order total, Etsy is cheaper below 19 orders a month (NZ$5.06 per order vs Shopify’s NZ$1.57 plus $65 NZD a month). Above 19 orders, the Shopify store is cheaper on fees alone.
Why is Amazon not compared?
Amazon referral fees vary by category and its Seller Central schedule is login-gated, so no Amazon figure could be verified from an official page. No Amazon numbers are shown rather than guessed ones.
Run your own numbers
These pages use one fixed scenario so the comparison is fair. Your prices and order volume change the answer — run them through the free tools: Breakeven Planner, Platform Crossover, Product Pricing & Profit. Every figure and its official source is on the Fee Index, and the method is on the Methodology page.
Compare more fees
Same method, different country or marketplace: eBay vs Shopify fees New Zealand · Etsy vs Shopify fees Australia · eBay vs Shopify fees Australia · Etsy vs Shopify fees Canada · eBay vs Shopify fees Canada · Etsy vs Shopify fees EU · Fee Index · Platform Crossover.