Tool · Compare
Where should I sell it?
One item, one price — nine platforms side by side. Etsy, eBay, your own Shopify store, Mercari, Poshmark, Depop, Vinted, Whatnot and TikTok Shop, ranked by what you keep each month at your order volume. United States fees, verified from each platform’s official fee page.
What this calculator does: It ranks nine platforms side by side on one item at one price — what you keep per order and per month at your order volume — the calculator updates instantly.
Your numbers
The answer
Simplified estimate — excludes sales tax / VAT from the fee base.
| # | Platform | Fees / order | You keep / order | Monthly net |
|---|
How it is calculated
For each platform: fees per order come from the Fee Index for a United States seller. You keep per order = revenue − product cost − your shipping cost − platform fees. Monthly net = orders × you keep per order, less the Shopify Basic subscription ($39/month) where it applies. The ranking is by monthly net, so the order changes with your volume — a platform with a subscription looks worse at 10 orders a month than at 100.
Worked example (defaults: $40 item, $8 shipping charged, $12 product cost, $5 shipping cost, 50 orders a month): Depop keeps the most at $1,448.30 a month ($2.03 in fees per order), then your own Shopify store at $1,426.40, TikTok Shop at $1,406.00, Vinted at $1,400.00, Mercari at $1,310.00, Whatnot at $1,305.40, Etsy at $1,299.50, eBay at $1,203.60 and Poshmark at $1,000.00. Two of those figures carry a platform-specific rule: Poshmark is modelled on the $40 price alone (buyer-paid shipping via a Poshmark label, no shipping charged and no shipping cost for you), and Vinted the same (buyer pays shipping, prepaid label, no seller fee). If you charged shipping on those two, their numbers would look different — and wrong.
The rates behind the ranking: Etsy $0.20 + 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 per order; eBay 13.6% + $0.40; Shopify 2.9% + $0.30 plus $39/month; Mercari 10% of price + buyer-paid shipping; Poshmark 20% of the price ($2.95 flat under $15); Depop 3.3% + $0.45 with no selling fee; Vinted no seller fee; Whatnot 8% commission + 2.9% + $0.30 processing; TikTok Shop 6% referral fee. Every rate is on the Fee Index with its official source.
Sources, all checked 12 November 2026: United States seller fees for Etsy, eBay, Shopify, Mercari, Poshmark, Depop, Vinted, Whatnot and TikTok Shop, from each platform’s official fee page — Etsy fees, eBay seller fees, Shopify pricing, Mercari help, Poshmark support, Depop help, Vinted, Whatnot seller fees and TikTok Shop seller university. Every rate is also on the Fee Index with its source and date.
What this tool does NOT include — read before deciding
- Discovery: marketplaces bring their own search traffic; your own store does not. The cheapest platform on fees can still be the wrong choice if nobody finds the listing there. Vinted is a second-hand market, Whatnot is built around live auctions, and TikTok Shop sells through video — format and audience matter as much as the fee.
- Buyer-paid fees: Mercari buyers pay a 3.6% Buyer Protection fee and Vinted buyers pay a Vinted fee (typically 5% + $0.70) on top of your price. You do not pay them, but your buyer sees a higher total, which can change whether the sale happens at all.
- Whatnot volume tiers: the 8% commission is the Standard tier. Sellers who do more volume in a four-week period unlock lower rates, down to 3% by category — and the portion of a sale above $1,500 in select categories carries 0% commission. Both would improve Whatnot’s ranking here.
- TikTok Shop rate reports: trade reports said the US referral fee rose to 8% on 4 August 2026, but TikTok’s own fee page still lists 6%, so 6% is used here. Check your Seller Center settlement if your statement shows a different rate. Creator commission is your choice and is 0% here unless you set it.
- Depop Boost: a sale from a boosted listing adds 12% of the item price (new listings from 23 March 2026). Not modelled — it only applies when a boost produced the sale.
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC): not included. Paid traffic can erase a fee saving — run the numbers with your real CAC.
- Refunds and returns, apps and plugins, taxes, fulfilment and storage, currency conversion, international fees, and category variations: not modelled. Most-common category rates are used; your category may differ — check your seller dashboard.
Why Amazon is not compared — explicit exclusion
Amazon is not in this tool, deliberately — not an oversight and not a “coming soon” badge. Amazon referral fees vary by category (roughly 8% to 45%) and FBA fees depend on size and weight, which this tool does not collect, and Amazon’s Seller Central schedule is login-gated and could not be verified from an official page. No Amazon numbers are shown rather than guessed ones. See the Fee Index for exactly what is missing.